Peace and Conflict Resolution Practices among the Otuo Community of Edo State, Nigeria: A Philosophical Inquiry
Okegwemeh, Michael Ehilodu,
Olabisi Onabanjo University, Ago-Iwoye
Email: [email protected]
Abstract
The study examined peace and conflict resolution practices within the Otuo community through a philosophical perspective, emphasizing peace as an integral aspect of the African lifestyle, intrinsically linked to spirituality. Utilizing primary data obtained from interviews alongside secondary sources, the research analyzed how Otuo's cultural beliefs and governance frameworks sustain peace. It investigated the concept of Iziemudo (peace) and its application through cultural mechanisms. The findings revealed that Iziemudo embodies a connection with the Supreme Deity, ancestral spirits, humans, and nature, symbolizing a 'bond of hearts' devoid of prejudice. This concept is shaped by spiritual and ancestral influences, including the veneration of Ira-Ghotuo and Irin-Ghotuo figures. Kinship notions such as Imighotuo and Imọo Oyonpa illustrate that Iziemudo extends beyond communal living. Essential components include Aata (truth), Ikheheeo (elders), and marital bonds. The study concludes that Iziemudo exists as an interconnected lifestyle, incorporating Ma'at to sustain harmony within indigenous governance and promote sustainable peace.
Introduction
The concept of peace is understood holistically within the framework of most African indigenous communities. Peace embodies a holistic way of life (Wane, 2011), as reflected in African Spirituality, interconnected in all that exists, including the Supreme Deity, ancestral spirits, humans, animals, plants, and inanimate objects (Nyawo, 2023). The concept of Ma’at, originating from Kemetic tradition, is essential to the African worldview and plays a pivotal role in promoting peace and harmony within communities. However, the diverse interpretations and applications of Ma’at among various African populations necessitate a nuanced and comprehensive understanding of its significance in fostering peaceful coexistence (Ekanola, 2017).
It is based on this African ontological framework that the understanding and achievement of peace can be established. The concept suggests a complex relationship between the material and metaphysical realms, as opined by Masango (2006). This concept underscores the intricate connections between the tangible and intangible aspects of existence. This framework for understanding peace is being reflected in the concept of the “Ovie of Otuo” (Fig. 1), which shows the significance of tradition and interconnectedness in a rotational system of rulership among the 12 quarters of Otuo. This is the true spirit of shared responsibility and accountability with the proclivity for promoting cohesive unity in Otuo land. In cultural anthropology, the rotational system of governance is an expression of the balance of power and representation among diverse quarters (Torelli & Shavitt, 2010). Despite the distinct quarters within Otuo land, an interconnectedness exists that transcends human imagination, seamlessly blending the spiritual and the physical to foster constructive peace. Employing the meta-thought of interconnectedness and transcendental relationships, this study explores the conceptual framework of peace and conflict resolution among the Otuo people.
Fig. 1 Uzoyare II, His Royal Highness Godfrey Aigbogun Rotimi, Ovie of Otuo
Tracing the Roots of Otuo: A Historical Perspective
The genesis of Otuo, akin to numerous other localities, is enveloped in multiple historical narratives. One account attributes Otuo's establishment to Oba Ozolua of Benin (Lawani, 1947). An alternative version connects it to the royal lineage of the Ooni of Ife (Lawani, 1947). A third narrative recounts the origins of Otuo, tracing back to a Benin prince who, after being excluded from the Ejere Festival, departed the palace to establish a settlement in the area now known as Otuo (Lawani, 1947). This study, which primarily aims to explore the narrative of peace among the Otuo people, prioritizes the first account due to its depiction of a unified group executing the Oba's directive. Such collective actions are interpreted as emblematic of peace. In contrast to the unity portrayed in the first narrative, which is the reason for its selection in this research, the story of the prince's protest against his mother, resulting in his departure from the Benin palace (Lawani, 1947), does not exemplify peaceful behavior. Similarly, Prince Otuaka's exits from the Ooni's Palace, driven by his conduct (Lawani, 1947), does not embody the essence of peace. Fig. 2, illustrating the primary entrance to Otuo from Afuze, implies peace through its passage through communities, such as Uokha, Igue, and Ake-Levbu. For several decades, these neighbouring settlements have maintained harmonious relations with the Otuo people. However, despite varying historical narratives regarding the origins of the Otuo community, a cohesive and enigmatic bond persists, uniting its twelve quarters within a distinct spirito-cultural belief system. This enduring connection has contributed to the community's esteemed reputation. The significance of this mysterious bond is evident in the historical account of Oba Ozolua.
Fig. 2 Otuo Main Entrance Road from Afuze
The Oba Ozolua-related Narrative
The historical account of Otuo, as recounted by Lawani (1947), stems from the narrative of Uguan, a son of Oba Ozolua of Benin. In a notable incident, Oba Ozolua convened his sons and instructed them to erect a grand wall. While most complied, Uguan dissented, an act consistent with the meaning of his name: "I do not serve anybody." Nevertheless, out of filial respect, Uguan proposed an alternative: he would participate if allowed to fabricate mud from palm oil. The Oba, intrigued, assented to this unconventional request. To facilitate this endeavor, he allocated thirteen companies: Ideyenuma, Aimuaraekpen, Umaikhihe, Oikhizumaeren, Obokhiome, Oboerha, Okhisabo, Okhisemakhorin, Alofuotuo, and Okhimi. Okhizoiku later joined following the loss of the Okhimi company in the Edo War (Lawani, 1947). Fig. 3 depicts the reddish fence of the Oba of Benin, purportedly constructed from palm oil by a cohesive team under Prince Uguan's leadership. The narrative describes an extensive exploration that led to the discovery of Okoseko, or "hill of nuts." The companies opted to establish a settlement there, attracted by the land's fertility and abundant palm trees. After producing sufficient oil, they returned to Benin to fulfill the Oba's directive. Upon completion, they permanently relocated to Okoseko with their families, a location now recognized as Otuo. However, there exists a scholarly debate regarding the etymology of "Otuo" or "Otwa." Some posit that it is a linguistic corruption of Ghotuo, potentially an abbreviated form of Otuorigbeva, which translates to "Twelve quarters in twelve places" in the Benin dialect (Lawani, 1947).
Fig. 1 The Great Wall of the Oba of Benin’s Palace
Spatial and Demographic Overview of Otuo
The Otuo community, recognized for its extensive cultivation of both cash crops, such as cocoa, and subsistence crops (Pogoson, 2016), is located in Owan East Local Government Area of Edo State, Nigeria. This local government area shares boundaries with Akoko-Edo Local Government to the north, Etsako-West to the east, Owan West to the southwest, and Esan Central and Uhunmwonde Local Government Areas to the south. Owan East is a vast administrative region comprising 69 towns and villages and is home to eight clans: Ikao, Ivbi-Mion, Ive-Ada-Obi, Otuo, Uokha, Igue, Emai, Ihievbe, and Ake-Levbu (Ogbomo, 1993).
Despite the diversity of its towns and villages, the inhabitants are collectively identified as an Edoid people-speaking group within the Benue-Congo language family (Schaefer & Egbokhare, 2015). However, Afemai remains the predominant language spoken in the region (Ikoyo-Eweto, 2018). According to unofficial data published on CityPopulation.de, the Owan East Local Government Area, which encompasses Otuo, had an estimated population of 228,500 in 2022, based on observed growth trends. In contrast, the official records from the 2006 Population and Housing Census, conducted by the National Population Commission of Nigeria (NPC), indicate that Owan East spans 1,240 square kilometres and had a population of 154,385, consisting of 81,847 males and 72,538 females (Media Nigeria, n.d.; Wikipedia, n.d.). Notably, Otuo, as the largest settlement within Owan East Local Government Area, depicts a significant case for scholarly investigation in understanding the dynamics of peace and conflict resolution.
The Otuo Spirito-Philosophical Ethos for Peace
The concept of "ethos," one of Aristotle's modes of persuasion alongside "logos" and "pathos," finds a parallel in the African spiritual notion of ma'at. While the Yoruba have their traditions systematically recorded in the Ifa corpus, the Otuo have primarily depended on oral traditions and storytelling to pass down their beliefs and values across generations (Okegwemeh, 2024). This approach involved the Ekpahee (elders) imparting to younger members the significance of Iziemudo (peace) through respect for the land's beliefs and values. However, oral tradition faces challenges of accuracy and preservation, as observed in various African and South American contexts (Mercer, 1979; Ogundele, 2006). This is exemplified in the oral narratives of Otuo cultural practices, which some have linked to fetishism due to the oral nature of transmission. This issue became particularly pronounced with the introduction of Christianity in Otuo, creating a divide between Christian converts and practitioners of indigenous religion. The oral nature of cultural narratives was further complicated by narrators promoting a form of "negative syncretism," which disrupted Iziemudo between Indigenous Christians and Traditionalists in Otuo. These challenges stemmed from the inherent limitations of oral tradition in terms of accuracy and preservation. Despite these issues arising from misunderstandings and misinterpretations, the cultural values and beliefs in their authentic form remain vital for maintaining historical continuity and cultural identity (Akoh, Odeh & Igwe, 2022). The oral tradition has enabled Otuo community members to trace their lineage to a collective identity, fostering social cohesion.
Otuo, as in other African societies, possesses the concept of peace (Iriabije, 2024), and utilizes the term Iziemudo to describe peace. The interpretation is a "bond of hearts" or the "oneness of minds" without prejudices. It represents a traditional method of "expressing relationships entrenched in harmony, unity, and agreement for coexistence." A "bond of hearts" or "oneness of minds" devoid of bias is reflected in the interpretation. It exemplifies a conventional approach to cultivating relationships based on harmony, unity, and consensus for peaceful coexistence. From a collective perspective, the Otuo community’s concept of Iziemudo (peace) aligns with Kwame Gyekye's notion of "communitarianism." This alignment emphasizes the significance of shared obligations and collective ideals in fostering Iziemudo (peace) and social cohesion.
Kwame Nkrumah, a Ghanaian-born political theorist renowned for his advocacy of Pan-Africanism, his prominent role in the Organization of African Unity (OAU), and as a recipient of the Lenin Peace Prize, elucidated the concept of "consubstantiality" in his philosophical work, "Consciencism: Philosophy and Ideology for Decolonization." In this work, he underscores the fundamental values of shared humanity and the interconnectedness of all human beings as essential for developing a society and a unified African identity. This framework aims to harmonize traditional African values with Islamic and Euro-Christian influences within the context of peace.
Some sacred texts express a unified front through peace philosophy. For example in the bible there is this question; "Can two walk together unless they agree?" (Amos 3:3). Also, the Quran in Surah Al-Hujurat (49:13) states: "O mankind, we have created you from male and female and made you peoples and tribes that you may know one another. Indeed, the most noble of you in the sight of Allah is the most righteous of you." In Hinduism, the concept of peace is reflected in relationships of harmony and unity with universal laws. This is exemplified in the principle of Dharma, as expressed in the Bhagavad Gita (18:63): "Deliberate on this fully in your mind, and then do as you wish." This was Krishna's advice to Arjuna, emphasizing the importance of cultivating a purposeful relationship with one's conscience, people, and the universe. The interconnectedness of Iziemudo (peace) to religious texts serves to establish that the concept of peace in Otuo land is not isolated from a spirito-philosophical perspective. The connectivity of the sacred texts with Iziemudo (Peace) is a deep reflection of the universality of human creation, equality, and purity of peace over race, tribe, and heterogeneity.
Iziemudo (peace) is deeply rooted in the beliefs and practices of Otuo, instilling values and fostering interactivity. This connectivity underscores the potential significance of Iziemudo (peace) as a guiding principle for Otuo's communal existence. From an anthropological perspective, the connection between Iziemudo (Peace) and spirituality is termed religiosity, implying that Iziemudo (peace) represents a "symbolic interaction" that intertwines the nature of religion and culture, laying the foundation for a belief system that influences the harmonious existence of the Otuo community. The Otuo norms and values emanating from the spiritual roots of Iziemudo (peace) express the relationship between religion and culture, facilitating "social cohesion" and "conflict resolution strategies" among the Otuo people.
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK, PERSPECTIVES, AND IMPLEMENTATION OF IZIEMUDO (PEACE)
- The Sacred Veneration of Ira-Ghotuo and Irin-Ghotuo
In Otuo land, spirituality, and ancestral veneration hold substantial philosophical import. The spiritual framework in Otuo aligns with broader African spiritual concepts, emphasizing the interconnection between ancestors, deities, and the natural world, encompassing both metaphysical and tangible realms. The Ejere narrative of Otuo's genesis underscores the reverence for Ira-Ghotuo and Irin-Ghotuo as the cornerstone of Otuo's ethos. This reverence profoundly influenced the moral character and lifestyle of the Otuo people, who steadfastly adhered to the guidance of these ancestral entities. The populace continued to align their conduct with the teachings ascribed to Ira-Ghotuo and Irin-Ghotuo, even after their era, often invoking the phrase, "What father and mother said is what we would do." This principle serves as a crucial foundation for understanding Iziemudo (peace) in Otuo land. Fig. 4 illustrates a gathering of the Ikehẹeo (Elders), who convene for social engagements and to address critical issues that threaten Iziemudo (peace) within the community. As clarified by Okegwemeh (2024) and in alignment with the perspective of Iriabije (2024), the term Ikehẹeo, while representing a hierarchical position of eldership, refers to those who hold a secondary command within the Otuo system of governance. The Ikehẹeo are regarded as the custodians of the community, tasked with overseeing its well-being. According to their accounts, each quarter of the community is represented by its own Ikehẹeo (Watchmen), who regularly convene at the Ẹẹkpo (Town Square) to uphold Iziemudo (peace) within the land.
Fig. 4 An Ẹẹkpo (Town Square) at Otuo
Remarkably, this philosophical paradigm endures, with the counsel of the Ekpahe (elders) still commanding significant respect within the community. While the influence of Christianity and the necessity to adapt to alternative cultural frameworks have diminished the role of these deities in decision-making processes, the fundamental principle of seeking guidance from "Ira and Irin-Ghotuo" persists. From an anthropological perspective, which emphasizes the examination of local contexts in constructing and harmonizing with other cultural conceptualizations, the ethos of Ira-Ghotuo and Irin-Ghotuo closely corresponds to the notion of Iziemudo (peace) in Otuo. This leads us to a fundamental belief that all members of the community are descendants of the progeny of Otuo, thereby fostering a sense of security and the absence of fear of harm (Okegwemeh, 2024).
Imighotuo signifies "Children of Otuo". The concept of Iziemudo (peace) and Iṣezo (conflict resolution) is predominantly a spirit-cultural construct, as Iziemudo (peace) occurs automatically due to the belief system. An alternative interpretation of Imighotuo is Imọọ Oyonpa, which denotes "children of one person". This expression of unity and interconnectedness transcends mere communal living. This metaphysical bond is referred to in anthropology as "kinship". The blood of oneness permeates the citizens as children of one person, establishing a robust foundation for Iziemudo (peace) and Iṣezo (conflict resolution). It is firmly believed that as members of the same family, regardless of the intensity of issues, they can be resolved within the Otuo family mechanism for Iziemudo (peace) to transcend.
Although contingent on the case, there are instances such as idẹẹ Obo, which constitutes “an unintentional act”. For example, a hunter may inadvertently kill another person in the bush while hunting. When such a case is presented, the Ikehẹeo (elders) would conduct an investigation, and if the case is determined to be "idẹẹ Obo", the Iziemudo (peace) process may recommend payment of a fine or performance of certain rituals to spare the individual's life. Adherence to the moral standards of Ira Ghotuo and Irin Ghotuo is essential to prevent unnecessary conflicts in Otuo society. Iziemudo (Peace), in this context, is defined as the maintenance of positive relationships. For an Otuo individual, integrating these values into one's life will facilitate Iziemudo (peace). While Otuo culture demonstrates openness to change and embraces Christianity and other cultural conceptualities, respect for traditional beliefs remains important. The unlawful appropriation of another's spouse is believed to provoke the ancestral spirits of the land, potentially leading to consequences. Furthermore, an elderly woman, Olayemi (2024), now late, had once emphasized that maintaining harmony in marriage is crucial, and certain sexual practices are considered taboo in Otuo culture. She specifically noted that "oral sex" is prohibited as it is not a traditional practice between Ira-Ghotuo and Irin-Ghotuo.
The concept of Amaadẹ sẹ eegbe, in its singular form, and Emaadẹ sẹ eegbe, in its pluralistic application, represents a deeply entrenched peace mechanism that has historically sustained the Otuo people (Okegwemeh, 2024). This ideological framework underscores the collective consciousness that all members of the community are interconnected, inclining a cultural ethos where harm against one’s kin is considered an abomination. It is widely acknowledged that communities, including Otuo, currently experiencing peace have, at some point in history, endured conflicts, and inter-tribal and intra-community disputes. However, Otuo's traditional peace-maintenance strategies have remained steadfast, rooted in the guiding principle that "it is taboo to see your brother’s blood." This belief system, which has historically governed social relations, continues to shape the community’s intrinsic perception of peace. The solidarity within Otuo is so deeply ingrained that disputes are resolved swiftly and amicably, often without public discord.
While Otuo has historically faced inter-tribal conflicts, these were external rather than internal. The most notable confrontation was against Ilorin invaders, who significantly diminished the size of one of Otuo’s largest quarters, a demographic impact that persists to this day. As documented by Lawani (1947), when the invaders initially attacked Osiepa quarters, the Otuo people refrained from retaliation, because the aggressors had some of their daughters married to Otuo men and known as Irhamha (our wives), having previously granted them access to their land. Their commitment to peace and hospitality led them to treat the invaders as kin rather than adversaries. However, as hostilities escalated to the point of drastically reducing the Osiepa population, Otuo was compelled to respond. Under the leadership of Obokhiome, the Otuo warriors ultimately repelled the invaders at Imovie, securing their territorial integrity (Lawani, 1947).
This historical episode highlights Otuo's deeply ingrained pacifist traditions, demonstrating that while the community values peace and inclusivity, it also possesses the capacity for strategic defense when its survival is threatened. The resilience of the Amaadẹ Sẹ Eegbe philosophy continues to guide contemporary Otuo society, reinforcing a collective identity centered on harmony, mutual respect, and conflict resolution. Otuo has historically maintained a robust support system for peace and stability deeply rooted in the philosophical construct of Amaadẹ Sẹ Eegbe (singular) or Emaadẹ Sẹ Eegbe (plural). While the forces of modernity may seem to obscure this traditional framework, a critical anthropological examination of the community reveals that its sustained peace is fundamentally anchored in kinship structures and the enduring socio-cultural bonds between brothers and Idegbe (sisters). This intrinsic relational ethos continues to serve as the foundational mechanism for conflict resolution and social cohesion in Otuo
vi. Aata (Truth) as it relates to attaining isemudo (Peace) and Isezo (conflict resolution) in Otuo.
In the English language, "truth" is defined as the correspondence between what is articulated, believed, or proposed and what is substantiated by evidence and observation. Morally, truth involves addressing issues with honesty and integrity, which implies reliability and sincerity. In scientific terms, truth is regarded as principles or facts that are validated and widely recognized as accurate. In Otuo, aata (truth) is perceived through a moral framework intertwined with ancestral connections. This indicates that Otuo's understanding of truth combines moral and spiritual elements. Matters such as land or marriage are managed according to the traditions of the land, with the awareness that any falsification or alteration opposes Ira and Irin Ghotuo. Furthermore, there is a belief that the Supreme Deity does not accept any form of dishonesty or insincerity. Therefore, aata, as understood in the English language, closely aligns with the Otuo perspective, integrating spirituality and morality to reflect what is genuinely true.
One of the esteemed teachers, Jesus Christ, in John 8:32, stated: "And you will know the truth, and the truth will make you free." The assertion that freedom is the outcome of truth is also reflected in conceptual principles found in Buddhism, where truth is regarded as a definitive path to enlightenment and liberation. Similarly, in Hinduism, the principle of Satya aligns with this concept, emphasizing truth as a means to “Spiritual Liberation”. The knowledge of aata (truth) is considered foundational by Ikhehẹeo (Elders) of Otuo, who view it as a liberating tool. Without it, Iziemudo (peace) cannot be achieved. Aata (truth) is the sole quality that earns the Ikhehẹeo (elders) respect (Iriabije, 2024).
In the community of Otuo, adherence to aata (truth) is a fundamental expectation for all members. Individuals who deviate from this principle are considered unsuitable to serve as Ikhehẹeo (elders), as these figures are regarded as the most reliable members of society, entrusted with the guardianship of aata (truth). There exists a profound belief and expectation that Ikhehẹeo (elders) will consistently uphold aata (truth). Consequently, when individuals present issues to them, they do so with the firm expectation that aata (truth) will be maintained.
The significance of aata (truth) in the perspective of the Ikhehẹeo (elders) and the words of Okegwemeh (2024) lies in its spiritual and transformative power. It is essential for personal growth and self-discovery. This perspective aligns with notable Greek and Western thinkers, including Plato, Sigmund Freud, and Carl Jung, who regarded truth as fundamental to achieving peace across cultural and religious boundaries. Similarly, Sophie Oluwole, in her work entitled: Philosophy and the Oral Tradition in Africa, underscores the importance of truth in attaining self-discovery and personal growth, which are intricately linked to Iziemudo (peace). Malidoma Patrice Somé, an African thinker and spiritualist, further emphasizes that truth is a powerful tool for achieving Iziemudo (peace). He asserts that truth (aata) transcends human understanding and possesses a spiritual identity that only spiritually attuned individuals can harness to attain it.
For this reason, the Ikhehẹeo (elders) of Otuo remain committed to speaking aata (truth), regardless of the consequences. The pursuit of aata (truth) as a means of achieving Iziemudo (peace) in Isẹzo (conflict resolution) has been a practice of the Ira and Irin Ghotuo (Historical Father and Mother of Otuo) and remains a cherished heritage of the Otuo community. In this context, aata (truth) is seen as a priori: not derived from experience but inherently pure and divinely distinct, serving as the foundation for achieving Iziemudo (peace) in Otuo land. Despite the challenges that Otuo faces today, the interconnectedness of aata (truth), Iziemudo (peace), and Isẹzo (conflict resolution) continues to resonate deeply within the people of Otuo.
v. Realizing Iziemudo through Isezo (conflict resolution)
Iheoo (the elders), according to Iriabije (2024), are hugely involved when resolving conflicts of any sort. In other words, they are the ones to give the final verdict, and what they say remains final. Although, before reaching the final stage, the conflict being examined might have undergone processes of investigation where groups at the lower hierarchy are mandated to make thorough investigations and come out with their findings. For example, in land disputes, Ikhehẹeo (the elders) cannot go into the bush to investigate because most land disputes come from farmlands which is far in the forest. They employ the investigative services of a select group from an age category known as Otu-nasa, the third-ranking body in the governing system of Otuo. The investigators (Otu-nasa) go into the bush to investigate. After the exercise, they come with their findings to the Ikhehẹeo (elders) who then take it from there. The fascinating thing about the realization of isemudo in Otuo land is that the Ikhehẹeo (elders) trust the investigative agents (Otu-nasa) and base Isẹzo (conflict resolution) on the information gathered. However, to be fairer in carrying out Isẹzo (conflict resolution), which is usually held at egboo (town square), if the parties or the party with the apportioned blame of encroachment is not satisfied, Ikhehẹeo (elders) will raise another group neutral (not from Otu-nasa) to investigate, which in law is called “Appeal Process”.
The adoption of the "appeal process" by Ikhehẹeo (elders) concurs with what Okegwemeh (2024) stated about following the spirito-philosophical practices of Ira-Ghotuo and Irin-Ghotuo is true. Otuo respects the rights of man because it was the practice of Ira and Irin Ghotuo. So, Ikhehẹeo (elders) always resonate with the spirit of their patriarch and matriarch to guide them in all they do because they believe that being impartial has several consequences. With this in mind, Ikhehẹeo (elders) allow neutral people to go into the bush to carry out a fresh investigation, without being biased, they would give Isẹzo based on the findings of the neutral people being sent. History has shown that most times, there is little or no difference in what the neutral people and the Otuo-nasa have found out. With the two witnesses, Iziemudo (peace) is attained.
Otuo cosmology, akin to the cultural beliefs and practices prevalent across Africa, places significant emphasis on the principles of "neutrality" and "impartiality.” This is apparent in the pursuit of Iziemudo (peace) within the Otuo land; these principles transcend mere moral virtues, embodying cosmic tenets that sustain balance, justice, and harmony in both spiritual and social domains. As previously noted, Iziemudo can be achieved in conjunction with aata (truth), as the existence of the Otuo community is attributed to the endeavours of Ira and Irin Ghotuo, who advocated for and defended aata (truth). The ancestors led lives marked by impartiality and untainted by personal affiliations, bribery, or emotions. They maintained a steadfast commitment to spiritual neutrality, underscoring that divine or spiritual forces remain unbiased and align solely with what is demonstrably true. These virtues constitute the cornerstone upon which Otuo is established today, providing the foundation for Iziemudo (peace) in the Otuo land.
The pursuit of Iziemudo (peace) in Otuo is deeply intertwined with the principles of neutrality and impartiality, which are fundamental in promoting communal unity. This approach aligns with the anthropological concept of internal cultural relativism, in which cultural practices are understood and evaluated within a specific context free from external biases. The Ikhehẹeo (elders) play a crucial role in this process, as they are entrusted with the responsibility of upholding aata (truth) in their perspective of Iziemudo. This emphasis on truth transcends social hierarchies, requiring the elders to maintain integrity, regardless of the status of those involved in conflicts. The traditional appeal process in Otuo underscores the importance of aata in achieving Iziemudo (Iriabije, 2024). This process reflects a deep-rooted cultural belief that aata (truth) is not merely a concept, but a vital force that breathes life into Iziemudo (peace). Qualification for eldership in Otuo society is intrinsically linked to one's ability to embrace and embody truth, suggesting that the community values wisdom and integrity over mere age or social standing. This cultural practice demonstrates how internal cultural relativism can foster a harmonious society by prioritizing aata (truth) and impartiality in conflict resolution, ultimately leading to sustainable peace within the community.
vi. Otuo couples for Iziemudo (Peace)
In Otuo society, marriage is held in high regard, and the resolution of marital conflicts has traditionally been approached with sensitivity. Reflecting the reverence for marital ma'at in African Spirituality, Otuo culture perceives marriage as a union grounded in harmony, balance, and reciprocity between partners. According to Iriabije (2024), unlike the resolution of land disputes, altercations, and other matters in ẹẹgbo (town square), marital issues are addressed privately and are not considered matters for ẹẹpa (outside). This is because, in African Spirituality, the marriage bond is viewed as the union of two souls sanctioned by ancestral spirits and deities. Consequently, individuals outside of marital partnerships are not involved in resolving marital conflicts. Notably, Otuo culture holds Oposo nrho muesẹẹ (wife) in high regard. When adjudicating matters concerning the couple and Oposo nrho muesẹẹ (married woman), male investigators face limitations to avoid contravening the traditional golden rule of the land, which mandates that the rights of Oposo nrho muesẹẹ (married woman) be prioritized and respected unconditionally. Violations of this right result in carrying out rituals to avert punishment from ancestral spirits. For instance, in cases of sexual issues between couples, male investigators are strictly limited in their investigations, as they are not part of the marital partnership bond. Investigators must exercise discretion in speech; failure to do so may result in a monetary fine or an obligation to perform certain rituals for lack of tongue use. The same applies to “Oposo su ma” (a non-Otuo wife). Marital crises are handled with care. Indeed, according to Iriabije (2024), Oposo su ma (a non-Otuo wife) possesses equal rights to indigenous married women. This aspect of the Otuo tradition is particularly noteworthy, as approaches to marital issues are characterized by profound respect for the spiritual connectivity bond, which does not discriminate between an indigenous married woman and Okposo su ma (non-native wife).
In numerous African communities, Iposo nrho muesẹẹ (married women-plural) are accorded a revered status due to their intrinsic connection to fertility and spirituality. Within the cultural frameworks of Otuo and other African belief systems, Iposo (women) are esteemed as essential intermediaries between the physical and spiritual domains. Their esteemed position is deeply entrenched in both cultural and spiritual traditions (Rasak 2016). As a result, interactions involving them demand a heightened level of caution, especially among men who adhere to African spiritual principles. In Otuo, it is imperative to exercise judiciousness and wisdom when engaging in Iziemudo (Peace)—the reconciliation process—between Irhamha (My husband) and Ohamẹ (My wife), or more broadly between omọọhi (man) and Oposo (woman). Across various African perspectives, Iposo (women) represent familial prosperity, abundance, and continuity through childbirth (Wane, 2002). Nevertheless, despite their spiritual and reproductive roles, they are subject to disciplinary measures if they violate social or moral norms (Iribije & Okegwemeh, 2024).
Conclusion
This study offers a comprehensive examination of the concept of peace and conflict resolution practices within the Otuo community, providing valuable insights into indigenous African methods for maintaining social harmony. The research underscores the holistic nature of peace in Otuo society, emphasizing its interconnectedness with spirituality, governance, and daily life. Key findings include the Otuo concept of 'Iziemudo' (peace), which is deeply rooted in spiritual and cultural beliefs, reflecting a broader African worldview that perceives Iziemudo peace as an interconnected way of life. The governance structure of Otuo, epitomized by the Ovie of Otuo, illustrates how traditional rotational leadership can foster social cohesion and shared responsibility. The role of elders (Ikhehẹeo) and the emphasis on truth (aata) in conflict resolution underscore the community's commitment to impartiality and justice. The Otuo approach to marital conflict resolution demonstrates a profound respect for the spiritual nature of marriage and the rights of women. This research contributes to the broader discourse on indigenous governance, spirituality, and sustainable peace, emphasizing the importance of understanding and preserving traditional knowledge systems in addressing contemporary challenges of conflict resolution and peacebuilding.
References
Akoh, J., Odeh, M., & Igwe, R. (2022). The Role of Oral Narratives in Building Peace in Nigeria. Creative Artist: A Journal of Theatre and Media Studies, 16(2), 35-55.
Ekanola, A. B. (2017). Yoruba conception of peace. The Palgrave handbook of African philosophy, 671-680.
Ikoyo-Eweto, E. O. (2018). Phonetic differences between Esan and selected Edoid languages. Journal Of Linguistics, Language and Culture, 4(1).
Masango, M. J. (2006). African spirituality that shapes the concept of Ubuntu. Verbum et Ecclesia, 27(3), 930-943.
Media Nigeria. (n.d.). History of Owan East LGA, Edo State. Retrieved April 16, 2025, from https://www.medianigeria.com/history-of-owan-east-lga-edo-state/
Mercer, P. M. (1979). Oral tradition in the Pacific: Problems of interpretation. The Journal of Pacific History, 14(3), 130-153.
Nkrumah, K. (1963). Speech at the OAU Summit, Addis Ababa.
Nkrumah, K. (1964). Consciencism: Philosophy and Ideology for Decolonization.consciencism.wordpress.com+1consciencism.wordpress.com+1
Nyawo, S. (2023). Indigenous Spirituality, Peacebuilding, and Development in Eswatini. In The Palgrave Handbook of Religion, Peacebuilding, and Development in Africa (pp. 287-303). Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Ogbomo, O. W. (1993). Men and women: Gender relations and the history of Owan communities, Nigeria c. 1320-1900.
Ogundele, S. O. (2006). Prospects and Challenges of oral traditions and ethnography for archaeological reconstructions: a case study of Tivland, Nigeria. Anistoriton Journal, 10, 1-13.
Pogoson, O. I. (2016). Some utilitarian objects from Edo North and the Northern Edo and Benin artistic relationship.
Razak, A. (2016). Sacred women of Africa and the African diaspora: A womanist vision of black women’s bodies and the African sacred feminine. International Journal of Transpersonal Studies, 35(1), 14.
Schaefer, R., & Egbokhare, F. (2015). Archaeological inspiration and historical inference. Language documentation and endangerment in Africa, 17, 253.
Torelli, C. J., & Shavitt, S. (2010). Culture and concepts of power. Journal of personality and social psychology, 99(4), 703.
Wane, N. N. (2002). African women and spirituality: Connections between thought and education. In Expanding the boundaries of transformative learning: Essays on theory and praxis (pp. 135-150). New York: Palgrave Macmillan US.
Wikipedia. (n.d.). Owan East. In Wikipedia. Retrieved April 16, 2025, from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Owan_East